Assistive vs Generative AI Writing Tools for Researchers 

by Elizabeth Oommen George
Assistive vs Generative AI Writing Tools for Researchers

Artificial Intelligence (AI) writing tools have become increasingly popular in recent months, offering new and exciting opportunities for content creation. These AI writing tools have become invaluable companions for researchers struggling with academic writing. But not all AI writing tools are created equal. There are two types of AI writing tools: assistive and generative, and it’s critical to understand the main differences between the two before using AI in research writing. In this article, we explore the differences between assistive and generative AI writing tools, their applications in research, and how to choose the right AI academic writing tool for your needs. 

Table of Contents

What are Assistive AI Writing Tools?

Assistive AI writing tools like Paperpal are designed to complement and support researchers throughout the academic writing process. They work by analyzing the text and offering suggestions for language, grammar, spelling, style, and tone to make your academic writing more clear, concise, and convincing. Assistive AI writing tools function as intelligent assistants, providing instant suggestions and corrections to help researchers quickly refine their work and produce high-quality written content.  

How can Assistive AI Writing Tools Help with Academic Writing?

Assistive AI writing tools aim to help researchers with tasks, such as academic translation, research writing, appropriate paraphrasing, or journal submission checks. They only work to enhance existing content, unlike generative AI writing tools that produce new content based on specific prompts. As academic writing requires a high level of attention to detail and accuracy, assistive AI writing tools are seen as the preferred choice for researchers and students. Here are some ways that assistive AI writing tools can help with academic writing: 

  • Grammar and Spelling: One of the most important aspects of academic writing is ensuring that the language of your paper is free of grammatical errors and spelling mistakes. Assistive AI writing tools can help by checking your writing for common mistakes and providing suggestions for corrections. 
  • Consistency and Style: Academic writing often requires the use of specific academic style guides and formats. Here, assistive AI writing tools can help check your academic writing for consistency issues and adherence to recommended guidelines and make suggestions for changes where necessary. 
  • Formal Tone: Academic writing requires the use of a professional and formal tone, and assistive AI writing tools can help ensure that your writing meets these key requirements. By identifying and suggesting ways to polish your writing, these tools help you consistently deliver high-quality academic content. 
  • Translation: Assistive AI writing tools are also able to support real-time translation of text from one language to another. Top AI writing tools like Paperpal translate text as you write, providing you with accurate text that can be copied and used in your academic writing.  

AI writing assistants are great if you want to polish your research paper and make it more effective for submission. These AI writing tools can help researchers avoid needless spelling errors, grammar mistakes, unclear sentences, logical flaws, or citation issues. It could also suggest better ways to phrase arguments, improve your structure and coherence, or add relevant references, which makes it ideal for researchers.   

What are Generative AI Writing Tools?

Generative AI writing tools are designed to create new content from scratch and can create entire sections or articles. ChatGPT by OpenAI, is one of the generative AI writing tools creating a buzz for it content creation abilities. It uses machine learning algorithms to write content based on patterns and relationships in existing text that ChatGPT has been trained on. However, it’s important to know that while AI writing tools like ChatGPT can write research articles, the content may not always be relevant, accurate, or trustworthy. Generative AI models work best for tasks that require novelty and creativity; for example, they can be used to create impressive text, visuals, audio, and video content based on specific prompts or data.  

How can Generative AI Writing Tools Help with Academic Writing?

Generative AI writing tools can be especially useful for researchers who need to generate large amounts of content quickly. By automating the initial stages of content generation, these tools help free up valuable time for deeper analysis and critical thinking. Here are some ways that generative AI writing tools can help with academic writing: 

  • Writing first drafts and outlines: Generative AI can be used to create the first drafts and outlines for academic essays and research paper abstracts. It’s best not to rely on ChatGPT or other such AI writing tools to write entire research papers – many top publishers have strict guidelines rejecting the use of AI for writing research papers.  
  • Effective responses: Generative AI writing tools can help you create clear, polite, compelling responses to peer review comments. It can also help to write impressive cover letters and other professional communication with top stakeholders. 
  • Research Summaries: Generative AI writing tools can help researchers save time by quickly summarizing large amounts of information and presenting it in a clear and concise manner. 
  • Data Visualization: Many generative AI writing tools can also create data visualizations, making it easier for researchers to communicate their findings to others. 
  • Brainstorming: Generative AI writing tools can also help researchers by generating new ideas and helping to spark creativity. 

Assistive vs. Generative AI Writing Tools: Which is Right for You?

The choice between assistive vs. generative AI writing tools depends on your specific needs and the type of writing you are doing. If you are working on a complex academic paper, assistive AI writing tools are your best option. These tools can help you catch errors and ensure that your writing meets the highest academic standards. On the other hand, if you need to quickly generate ideas or a large amount of content, a generative AI writing tool may be more appropriate. 

Assistive AI writing tools have several advantages over generative AI for editing research papers. 

  • More focused on quality than quantity. Assistive AI writing tools aim to improve the existing content rather than generate new content that might be redundant or irrelevant. 
  • More reliable and trustworthy. Assistive AI academic writing tools use specialized data sources that are relevant to academia and specific research domains, including papers, journals, databases, or style guides. Generative AI models rely on general data sources that might contain inaccurate, biased, or outdated information. 
  • More collaborative and respectful. Assistive AI writing tools work with humans as partners rather than competitors. They respect the author’s voice and style and do not try to replace them. Generative AI writing tools might produce content that is inconsistent, inappropriate, or even plagiarized, which may lead to trouble for researchers. 

AI writing tools for researchers are becoming increasingly popular for both personal and professional writing. But if you’re looking to use AI to help with academic writing, it’s critical to understand the difference between assistive vs. generative AI writing tools so you can choose the right one.  

Paperpal is an AI writing assistant that help academics write better, faster with real-time suggestions for in-depth language and grammar correction. Trained on millions of research manuscripts enhanced by professional academic editors, Paperpal delivers human precision at machine speed. Try it for free or upgrade to Paperpal Prime, which unlocks unlimited access to premium features like academic translation, paraphrasing, contextual synonyms, consistency checks, submission readiness and more. It’s like always having a professional academic editor by your side! Go beyond limitations and experience the future of academic writing. Get Paperpal Prime now at just US$12 a month!

You may also like